Pulling at the Red Thread of Fate - Chapter 6 - Through Thick and
Thin...
Several days passed and nothing changed. Friday evening was still
counting down and with every passing minute, I could feel dread building
in my body. Was I the one who was nervous? Or was it Ally? I drilled
it into my head over and over again: it's just another Friday night
hanging out with Mike, watching some game footage and doing what 'bros'
do. There's absolutely nothing to be nervous about because nothing else
WILL happen.
Jen still seemed quite clingy to me, maybe even protective, but I
couldn't find a way to bring it up without potentially offending her. I
started noticing how the girls around me were always close with their
friends, whether it was walking arm in arm or constantly hugging each
other, so maybe this was normal for Jen and Ally. I wasn't afraid of
intimacy by any means, but I was definitely not the 'hug on first sight'
type of guy. I thought about asking her to join Mike and I tonight, but
I felt the pull of Ally's will, manifesting itself as both fear and
foreboding dread, convincing me otherwise. We did spend lunch together
as I had promised, and she seemed happy to have my undivided attention
for at least half an hour a day.
It got really awkward when we got home on Thursday, when after Steve had
slipped back into the house, she cornered me in the car and shoved
something in my hand. Feeling the square-shaped plastic with the
instantly recognizable feeling of a circle outlined in the package, I
knew exactly what it was. I hated that I turned red, blushing with
embarrassment. In response, I practically threw the condom back at her.
Then she started to get embarrassed and thrust it back at me, telling
me, "You have to be careful!"
I had already resolved that it would NEVER get that far, but no manner
of convincing would be enough for her and after a few minutes of back
and forth, I finally relented and shoved the condom into my bag just to
get her to let it go. Of course, I had to ask her, "Where did you even
find one anyway?"
She looked sheepishly before turning her head up to look at her house.
It took me a hot second to make the connection, but the first word to
come out of my mouth was, "Eww." I covered my mouth, embarrassed at
what I had just said, and looked apologetically at her.
There was a pregnant pause between us - no pun intended - as I waited
for her to react... but thankfully she started laughing, which made me
laugh as well. She did say something that would probably haunt me more
than any dream about Mike though, "What do you think your Dad does with
your Mom when you and Steve aren't around?"
I reacted the only way I could: "EWW!"
Fits of laughter ensued as the thought of our parents having sex was
suddenly the most hilarious thing we'd ever thought about. When Dad
came out to check on me after being outside for so long, it was Jen's
turn to say "Eww!" and we started laughing all over again. Dad was not
amused, knowing that he was the butt of some joke, but not quite sure
what it was. He rolled his eyes and tapped on the windshield, motioning
for us to go inside before leaving us to our laughter.
When we had finally calmed down, I pulled the condom out to look at it
and said, "I'm pretty sure this is almost as old as we are."
Jen chortled and tried not to laugh again and shrugged her shoulders,
"You could always buy some tomorrow, or maybe grab some from the
guidance counsellor's office."
Oh god. The walk to the 'candy bowl' was always the source of rumours -
I know some guys going on purpose to grab a condom just so they COULD be
seen. But why was I even thinking about this? SEX WAS NOT AN OPTION.
"I'm fine", I told her with confidence as we left the car.
She smiled softly at me and gave me a 'sure there' look before
admonishing me, "I'm going to channel both our Moms here and tell you
that you should be careful..." She winced and added, "And don't worry,
I won't say anything... although you should tell your parents where
you'll be tomorrow."
It hadn't occurred to me to even tell them I'd be at Mike's since that
was just something I did all the time. If I'm going through with this,
it'll be much better to beg for forgiveness than to ask for permission
anyway. I shrugged noncommittally at Jen and told her I'd see her
tomorrow before we parted ways and went into our respective houses.
I should mention that Violet pretty much left me alone after she found
the pamphlet. She was definitely not friendly, but it seemed that
particular drama was over. Or at least she seemed to tolerate me
instead of despise me. The fact that there weren't even more rumours
flying around about me meant that she didn't say anything to anyone, of
which I'm grateful. Not because I would have been afraid of any
rumours, but it would have been yet another distraction on my way to try
to get home. I only felt guilty because it felt like I had 'tricked'
Violet somehow. That I had lied to her to play on her sympathies. But
I wasn't going to bring it up with her at least - there didn't seem to
be any reason to tell her the truth. Well, to be honest, I'm also not
sure what the 'truth' would be anyway.
Perhaps the strangest moment was when I took a hard fall from a lift and
Violet came over to check if I was alright. Her Gaggle chalked it up to
her being nice because she had to as the captain, but the moment between
us seemed genuine. Although I'm pretty sure I could see her twitch
whenever one of the girls would mention the 'thing' between me and
Mike...
Britney on the other hand couldn't help but butt into my life at that
point. The little endless ball of energy was practically everywhere I
went, happy to give me tips on what Mike's hobbies were and what he
liked in a woman. I didn't actually need her help that much, because he
sounded very much like the Mike I knew, but I realized that we never
really did talk about the type of woman he wanted to be with. Now that
I thought about it, I'd go on and on to him about Violet and he'd simply
agree with whatever I said and never offered up anything himself.
That said, Britney wasn't all that insightful about Mike's turn-ons,
beyond "smart, cute, sexy, but also fun". Generic enough that,
honestly, Britney could have fit the bill if I had to be honest with
myself.
I didn't mind having Britney be so involved though. It was nice to have
a "wing woman" who was so into hyping me up that I couldn't help but
feel good about myself... even if it was all in service of trying to
pair me up with Mike. In less than a week, she made me sound like a
legend to the other cheerleaders on both the Varsity and JV teams,
making me into some kind of authority on love.
If... when I get back, maybe I should let my wandering gaze, well,
wander past Violet and toward Britney. She'd definitely be a great
girlfriend. Or perhaps the worst. It'd probably be a trip finding out
though.
Friday soon approached and for the first time this week, I let Jen drive
us to school. Steve tried his best to ignore our conversation, hoping
to not be culpable in whatever crime I was going to commit in Mom's
eyes.
"So, are you really going to go through with this?" she said with a
little disappointment in her voice.
I actually did want to talk to Mike - to try to understand what happened
to his parents. It was still a subject I couldn't really broach with
Britney, and even if it might not have any bearing on whatever was
happening to me, it could be useful information to have. Being alone
with him would definitely make asking that easier, and I feel like I had
already promised Ally - whatever that means - that I'd go through with
this 'date' anyway.
"Yes... but really, if you're that worried, you could..." I felt little
frog in my throat and coughed loudly to clear it, "you could always come
with me."
Jen rolled her eyes at me. "Now you're just making fun of me again."
I just sighed and let it go, because the last thing I wanted was another
awkward fight between us again. When we arrived at the school and
parked, Jen told Steve to meet her after school and that she'd take him
home early.
He let out a little cheer and cheekily said, "Can you keep going out
with Mike so I don't have to hang around school waiting for your
practices to end?"
I chased him around the car for a bit and threw him a playful kick to
get him out of my hair, watching him laugh as he ran toward the school.
When I turned to face Jen, she had that deep, serious look on her face
again and suddenly gave me a hug, pulling me close to her in a tight and
intimate embrace. It felt like an eternity when she finally released
me, particularly because we were in front of the school, but when she
did pull back from me, I saw a sad wistful look on her face. With a
melodramatic tone she started, "I always thought..."
I waited for her to finish, but she didn't have the chance as Hurricane
Britney stormed right in and greeted us with her Pollyanna cheeriness.
"Hiiii Jen," Britney greeted her in a sing song voice. Jen clutched my
arm and mumbled a hello in response. I suppose this was better than the
complete silence from her previously. Britney turned back to me and
continued, "Operation Two to Tango! Is a go."
I sighed. After a couple of days of this, I knew she was trying to get
a rise out of me. Instead I opted not to play along this time, "Look, I
appreciate you trying to get your parents out of hair, but I'd honestly
feel better if they were there. You too."
"Oh Ally, how can you be such a man-eater but also be so inexperienced?"
I know she was needling me, but I'm not sure if I appreciated being
called a man-eater. Perhaps Jen sensed my anxiety and exclaimed,
"Ally's not that kind of girl!"
I stopped in my tracks as both Britney and I stared at her for a minute.
Realizing her outburst, Jen turned her head away from us and buried her
face into her hands in embarrassment. I wasn't sure this is how I had
expected to break her out of her shell, but it was certainly effective.
Britney quickly grabbed Jen's hands into hers and smiled sweetly at her,
"I'm sorry Jen! I was just having a little bit of fun. I know she's a
perfect angel. Right Ally?"
I shook my head in exasperation but smiled back in return, "I feel like
you've both been having too much fun at my expense lately."
Britney squealed with laughter and said in return, "I like seeing you
make your faces whenever I talk about Mike. It's so cute!" She pulled
Jen and I closer and in a conspiratorial tone said, "But really, Mike is
a great guy and I know he won't try anything, so I'm just saying...
Ally, you have to make the first move and this is the perfect time."
I remembered the dream where I kissed Mike passionately on the football
field and a warm feeling washed over my body. Would it be so bad to
feel good, just for a moment? And... it's not like this is my Mike...
it wouldn't be his lips pressing back against mine, or his hands
touching greedily at my body, so it'd be fine. I angrily shook my head
to clear those thoughts, which Britney took as me trying to deny wanting
to make the first move.
"Oh Ally, I know what you're really thinking. But that's okay, we can
play it slow too."
Jen broke off from us and asked Britney, "Why do you want Ally to be
with Mike so badly anyway?"
It was a thought that had crossed my mind, although I never thought to
articulate it. She did seem really invested...
She laughed again and said, "Because it's so romantic! They could
become high school sweethearts, and then go to prom together, and then
get married!"
Jeez! That was a spit-take moment if there ever was one.
It was my turn to blush as I started walking toward school on my own,
"Let's... let's get to class. We don't want to be late."
Britney giggled and poked Jen, "See! Tell me that isn't so adorable!"
"Ally's always adorable," Jen muttered to herself, perhaps a bit too
loudly because she was caught off guard when Britney hooked her arm into
hers and began to lead her to school behind me.
Britney happily agreed, "I'm glad you think so too!"
If I had turned around, I probably would have seen Jen blushing.
They soon caught up with me and Britney, in a moment of seriousness,
told me, "Sorry if I've been teasing you too much. I think you really
should have some alone time with Mike, away from peering eyes. I think
you'll like him even more when you get to know him."
Oh Britney, if you only knew. I know him quite well - perhaps too well,
considering I've seen him in his birthday suit. But clearly there were
things about this Mike that would be different... like having a nosy
little sister to deal with! I nodded perhaps too solemnly and said,
"And getting to know him is all that's going to happen."
Britney just flashed me a smile that was both infuriating and disarming
at the same time. I really just couldn't stay mad at this girl, and all
I could do was roll my eyes at her as I turned back to stuff my things
into my locker.
It was at that moment Violet and Anna, who I would describe as the
leader of the Gaggle and who seemed to be Violet's version of 'Jen',
passed by us. Violet barely acknowledged my existence, but she did
offer a brief but significant, "Ally" before passing me.
"Violet," I whispered back in response. I still gave her a wide berth,
but I still didn't quite know what to do with her.
Anna was not pleased and shot me a dirty look as if to remind me of my
place.
As they walked down the hallway, I could see that Jen had practically
'chameleoned' herself against the lockers and disappeared when Violet
had arrived, skittish as ever, while Britney just continued to smile at
me with a sparkle in her eyes. I shook my head at Britney and simply
said, "Don't start..."
She gave me a playing jab with her fingers in response and laughed,
"You're so funny Ally!" She paused for a moment and sighed wistfully,
"I'm going to be sad when you're gone..."
I cocked my head and looked at her quizzically. I think I had joked
that she might be responsible for all of this, but... I tentatively
asked her, "Gone?"
"You know, when you graduate. I bet you end up going to the State
school or somewhere big, so I probably won't see you again for a while
once you're gone."
Oh right. Graduation. Although I wouldn't put it past Britney to be
some kind of magical creature who was having fun messing with me. I
smiled at her and said, "I'm sure we'll always be in touch wherever we
end up."
She had a mischievous look on her face again and I braced myself as she
said, "Especially if you end up being my sister in law."
Jen suddenly reasserted her presence by clearing her throat rather
loudly, which was so perfectly timed that it caused me to start laughing
uncontrollably at how ridiculous this whole situation was. Being Mrs.
Taylor? I couldn't even imagine. No, actually I didn't WANT to
imagine.
I didn't wait for either of them to react and started walking to class,
"See you both later."
As I went through my day, I thought about how I was beginning to settle
into my 'new' life. I hated that it was beginning to feel routine...
normal... but I had no idea what I could do while I waited for the
professor to get back to me. I'm not sure if going back to Pastor Jones
would help, particularly because I still find myself unable to
articulate my situation in a coherent manner that wouldn't be
misinterpreted. I should count my blessings she didn't think I was
crazy, or tell me that I needed to be 'fixed', considering some of the
stories I read about online about people who 'came out'. I'm not sure
if I saw what was happening to me as a punishment from above, and I
don't know if a fire and brimstone approach would solve anything.
I had another surprise episode with Violet when, before practice, she
took me aside and told me to focus. Echoing the Coach, she firmly told
me, "Keep your mind on the routine or someone will get hurt."
Just as with Britney and Jen, I wanted to tell her that my mind was all
on practice, but the mixture of awe and fear still intimidated me and
all I could do was nod. I wonder if Ally had wanted to be a part of her
group, but for whatever reason was shut out. Maybe I'm supposed to help
Ally with that?
She stared at me intently for a moment, perhaps trying to glean some
information from me by reading my mind. Hey Violet, I'm actually a guy!
From the expression on her face, that didn't seem to work, but I figured
mind reading wouldn't be any more unusual than what's happened to me at
this point. Whatever she was trying to glean from me, I could tell from
the consternation in her face that she wasn't satisfied, but rather than
interrogate me further she simply walked away from me and joined the
others at practice.
I appreciated her words though, because it got me to focus on practice
instead the big event that was supposed to happen tonight. Funny
enough, or perhaps as yet another joke the universe played on me, Coach
Sanders ended football practice early to let the boys have some time to
blow off some steam, giving those who were interested time to watch the
girls practice instead. I couldn't help but feel Mike's eyes on me once
I noticed that he was watching us.
After we finished our routine, he came up to me with a water bottle and
smiled his winning smile at me before jokingly adding, "You know, you
might want tuck yourself in a little to create a straighter line."
As I squeezed the water bottle and took a drink, I smiled back at him
and said, "Fair play." I turned to Britney, who was talking to some of
the other girls, "Although I'm more inclined to suspect that you got
that pointer from someone else."
He laughed and said, "Yeah, although I did get a chance to see you last
year when you were with the JV team. You were amazing."
I turned to face him and I could tell he was being sincere, which only
made me blush. But as I played with a blade of grass with my foot, a
thought occurred to me. Why am I feeling embarrassed?!
Perhaps feeling a little more confident at my expense, he continued,
"So, how about we meet at the parking lot when you're ready? You're
still okay with coming over to my place?"
I looked up and thought about the whole point of this little escapade.
I needed to find out more about his life and maybe along the way help
him with his game. This was intelligence gathering! "Yep, that works
for me," I quietly add before tossing him the water bottle and turning
back to face the other girls.
We both flinched when we saw Britney approach us and I gave him a
knowing look, "Are you as afraid of her as I am?"
He looked at me and said with mock seriousness, "At least you don't have
to live with her."
We shared a laugh as Britney finally approached us and asked, "What's so
funny?" We turned to face each other again and just burst out into
laughter once more, making her pout at us. But an evil glint in her eye
appeared and she smiled, "You two already have an inside joke! Soon
you'll be giving each other knowing glances like Brian and Mom!"
Mike hurried apologized on her behalf and stuttered out, "I-I-I'm sorry
about her. She doesn't know what she's talking about."
"I think we just need to learn to return fire, Mike. Maybe we should
help Britney find your new brother in law? Or how she's going to be our
go-to babysitter from now on?"
Britney squealed in delight at my attempt to get back at her, "There's
the man-eater bite!"
I playful started to chase her and she ran back to join the other girls,
sharing a laugh with them when she got back to them.
Mike caught up with me and kept a weary eye on Britney when he mused,
"Well, I don't think I ever thought of shooting back."
"It's like being on the field. Find that area with no coverage and
boom! Hit your receiver."
He looked down at me and gave me an amused look, "You really do like
football, don't you?"
I could feel my body beginning to respond with embarrassment, but I
fought the feelings and nodded vigorously, "You could say it was... it
IS my life."
A third voice interrupted our conversation, "I thought that was
cheerleading."
Oh shit. I snapped around and saw Violet with a stern look on her face
and immediately felt guilty for seemingly disappointing her. This time
I felt as embarrassed as Ally did for getting on Violet's bad side and
coughed out a quick apology, "Y-yes, of course!"
Violet eyed Mike up and down as if she was examining a convict or
perhaps a prisoner waiting for the firing squad and narrowed her eyes
before jabbing a finger at his chest, "If you think this little trifle
isn't going to be a distraction during your big homecoming game next
week, be my guest. But when our competition season starts you and your
little boys better not mess with my team." She then turned to me and I
braced myself to be berated just as well, but she leaned in close to me
and whispered quietly to me in my ear, "And maybe you should be more
honest with yourself."
She marched away from us and told everyone that they could wrap it up
and head home, causing the girls to erupt in cheers and talk about the
plans they had for the start of the weekend. I think we were both a
little shellshocked by Violet, as we stood in the metaphorical dust that
Violet kicked up in her wake. Mike was the first to respond, "I'm
not... I mean, I care about football too. But you're not... I mean I'm
serious. No, I mean, not serious like Britney thinks we should be but
I'm not... like this isn't about scoring with you and..."
I couldn't help but find Mike sweet as he stumbled over his words. This
really was a side of him I didn't know existed, and there was
something... nice about being able to get to know him in a way I never
would be able to back in my normal life. I also felt a little guilty
watching him stumble around with his words and saved him by patting his
arm, "Don't worry, I know you're not like that. You're too much of a
gentleman." At least, Mike and I never really talked about girls as
'conquests' anyway. I gestured to the school and added, "She's not
wrong though. We need to focus on getting you ready. Let's go get
changed and then we can see what we can do about your game."
"Alright, I'll see you soon!"
As we went our separate ways, I thought about what Violet said to me.
She didn't really have any reason to believe I wasn't questioning
myself, but it felt dishonest to have her sympathy for that reason and I
wanted to tell her the truth. Except... what is the truth? Ally's
clearly attracted to Mike and I'm clearly not. Definitely not! So,
what could I tell her?
In the locker room, Britney was already telling an enraptured audience
about the evening I had planned with Mike and I just waved them off when
they all started to tease me about my 'date' when I walked in. Jaina
did try to give me some advice on how to handle Mike based on her
experience with her ex-boyfriend, but I assured her that it would not be
needed. Violet, for her part, just gave me a stern look as she passed
me on the way out of the locker room.
When I was ready to leave myself, Britney explained to me, "So, Mom's
going to pick me up and then we're going to meet Brian at the station
before going out to dinner."
"And they're actually fine with me and Mike being alone together?"
"This is where the awkwardness of a blended family comes in. Mom is
pretty happy-go-lucky, but she is still trying to figure out what
boundaries to set for Mike and I know Brian freaks out whenever I ask
him for something a little too earnestly," Britney replied. It was odd
to hear her be so serious, but I suppose she couldn't be cheery all the
time. I wonder if calling Mike's dad Brian was to tease him too, or a
little bit of unease on her part... That said, I didn't have much time
to linger on the thought, given how quickly she returned to form when
she asked, "Besides, I thought nothing would happen tonight anyway?"
It felt like a challenge and I wasn't going to let her win, "Thanks for
reminding me Britney." She looked at me with a curious look on her face
as I pulled out my phone and placed a call. I wasn't sure if I should
be thankful that she was still working and I got her voice mail, but it
gave me an opportunity to leave a message without having to deal with
her reaction... at least until I saw her later tonight. "Hey Mom, I
forgot to let you and Dad know that I was going to come home late
tonight. I'm going to be helping Mike Taylor out with some football
stuff. Anyway, love you Mom!"
Britney's expression turned to one of surprise as she nodded at how
forthright I was with my message, "Looks like you're serious about it
being 'serious'. But do you think your Mom's going to appreciate you
leaving a last-minute message about her poor, sweet daughter being swept
away by a dashing young man. Their hormones and lust driving them to
throes of passion!" She hugged herself and made kissing sounds at me
before bursting into a fit of laughter.
Yeah, she opened the door and I walked right into that one, didn't I?
Choosing not to concede defeat, I told her, "Stella and I have very
mature relationship." I immediately felt like a child as the words left
my mouth because we could both tell from my lack of conviction that I
was simply putting on airs.
Britney jabbed me with her elbow and laughed, "Such a bad girl!" We
waved to the girls who were still lingering in the locker room and
started walking through the halls of the school and Britney continued,
"So I'll text you when we're going to head home in case you need to put
on your clothes and pretend nothing's been going on."
I groaned, "Britney..."
She looked at me and gave me an apologetic smile, "Sorry, I know that
sometimes I can go a little too far. But I'll still give you both a
heads up... just in case!"
I didn't have the energy for a riposte so I let her win before she gave
me a wink and we split off in different directions. As I went out to
meet Mike, I wasn't really sure how I should feel. I imagine being in
Ally's position and approaching this as an actual first date, if only
for her sake, but the idea of seeing Mike in that way couldn't help but
make me laugh. I was more worried about saying or doing something that
would make me seem like a crazy stalker, but what really kept me
preoccupied was getting a glimpse of his current life with a step-mother
and a step-sister.
I wouldn't say our relationship was totally superficial, but if he had
any family troubles, he never let me know about them. Is this version
of Mike happier than the one I knew?
I could see Mike chatting with a couple of the guys as he waited by his
car. When they saw me, they gave him a knowing nudge - guys really
aren't subtle are they? - as they quickly dispersed and left us alone.
I suppose I felt the need to channel my inner Britney and teased him
about it when I arrived at his side, "Already telling them about the
exploits you'll have tonight?"
He was already beginning to get all flustered so I gave him a playful
jab in the gut, "I'm kidding!" I nudged him aside so I could open the
door and toss my bags into the back before getting into the passenger
side seat. I watched as he awkwardly shuffled around to the other side
of the car before joining me inside. I tried to imagine what it'd be
like if I actually had the guts to ask out Violet... or anyone for that
matter. I'd probably be nervous wreck myself.
I could hear him take a deep breath before he started the car, turning
to me as he starting backing out of the parking lot, "So I heard you
like Joe's, so I thought we'd get some burgers to take out before
heading over to my place." My mouth began to water as I pictured the
burgers Dad brought home the other day. It couldn't hurt to indulge one
more time, could it?
"Sounds great, but who told you?" I paused for a second but answered my
own question, "Britney!"
"Yeah..." he sheepishly replied as we began the drive. "I've never
been, but... but everyone likes a burger, right?"
I pondered his rhetorical question as I recognized yet another,
admittedly insignificant, change in his life. It was a mainstay of my
life because my Dad would go there often with his crew and I'd often tag
along when I worked for him in the summer so I definitely developed a
taste for whatever they did behind the kitchen to the burgers as they
put them on the grill. Mike never was much of a discerning epicure, so
he might have had a reason to go there on his own. Well, even if I
can't help him improve his game, the least I could do is introduce him
to the best burger in the country.
I turned to face him, a serious look crossing my face and said, "This
isn't just a burger. This is THE burger."
"I don't know... there's a place by Dad's office that's pretty good."
"The Shack? Gross!" I flinched as I just realized that I said
something that I shouldn't have known again. But I just couldn't let
him compare that trash to Joe's!
If he caught my mistake, he didn't let on. Perhaps to my chagrin, The
Shack's popularity probably saved me from myself. Probably the only
good thing The Shack has ever done! Instead, he laughed at my response
as we began to pull into the parking lot in front of Joe's, "I didn't
know you had such refined tastes."
I let out a small sigh of relief at the fact that he seemed to let yet
another one of my minor slips go without notice, but couldn't help
myself and pushed him a little further by adding, "I couldn't be friends
with someone who thought The Shack had better burgers than Joe's."
"Well that's convinced me. I don't even need to taste them to know that
I love them!"
We both laughed as we exited the car. Although I'm sure relationships
have ended over things more trivial than favourite burgers. When we
approached the front doors, I hesitated for a second as I thought about
how I'd be received here. Dad was a regular and they knew me quite well
from all the times I tagged along with him. It'd be strange being in a
place that was familiar where no one recognized me, but I suppose that
would be the case for most of my time here.
Even early in the evening, the place was packed with a mixture of people
coming off work wanting a juicy, sloppy burger to families coming by for
dinner. Thankfully I didn't see anyone from school, so at least my
little outing with Mike could remain private for a little longer.
"Little Ally!" I heard the unmistakable voice of Frank, the man who
inherited the restaurant from the eponymous owner probably a decade ago.
I was happy to be recognized, although being called 'Little Ally' was a
little disconcerting. He ambled up to me with a big smile on his face,
"Your father had come in earlier this week with a special order from
you, so I hear!"
I was about to respond but I realized that I had no idea what to call
him. Ally certainly wasn't a stranger to him, but I still took the safe
route and began with, "Hi Mr. Ricci, it's nice to see you again."
He was mock offended and asked, "Who is this Mr. Ricci huh?" His smile
and jovial tone were always so infectious and I could feel myself
relaxing as he led Mike and I to a couple of spots at the bar.
"Sorry, Uncle Frank!"
"Now that's a good girl. We're busy now, but I'm sure I can fit you in
soon."
That was when Mike interrupted, "A-actually, we're going to be ordering
out."
I supressed a giggle as I saw Frank eyeball Mike up and down, examining
him as if he was about to interrogate a suspect. Lucky for Mike his Dad
was a cop and even without knowing the trouble he would have gotten into
when he was younger, I had to believe he was totally used to the perp
treatment by now. Certainly, many boys would have withered under
Frank's interrogating gaze. Perhaps Britney was rubbing off on me
because I had to suppress the urge to make a joke about Mike's
intentions for me and instead went with a thought that would play on
Frank's ego a little bit, "It's his first time and I said your burgers
are the best."
Mike nodded quickly and joined in, "It was all she talked about on our
way here."
Frank smiled at us and beamed in pride as he said, "A true lady with
excellent tastes."
"Could we get a couple of doubles with fries?" I was about to continue
by explaining Mike's preferences but thankfully caught myself before I
said anything. Instead, I offered my own preferences and gave Mike an
opening to include his own, "The works for me, with extra cheese
please."
"No pickles with mine... sir." The salutation stumbled out of his mouth
as if he felt the need to be respectful. I couldn't help but laugh, the
sight of Mike stumbling when speaking with Frank amusing me to no end.
I decided to save Mike from himself and added quickly, "I've got this."
Instinctually I reached for my wallet and found myself patting my butt
like an idiot searching for something that wasn't there. That gave Mike
the opportunity to offer up his own card to Frank, who gave Mike a wry
smile in return before asking Mike to walk over to the to the register
with him.
They were out of earshot, so I could only imagine what they were talking
about. Like Pastor Jones, it seems that Frank has known Ally since she
was a child as well, although I'm not sure if I suppose one thing I
shared in common with her is that we both spent more time coming here
for burgers than going to Church. I wondered if Frank was giving him
advice on how he should treat me, playing the part of the protective
parental figure.
I watched as Frank patted Mike on his back and they parted ways, Mike
slowly walking back to me with a pensive look on his face. "Do I want
to know?" I ask as he sat next to me at the bar.
"Well, I'm thoroughly frightened. I can't even imagine what your Dad
would be like."
I laughed and jabbed him with my elbow, "Honestly it's my Mom you should
be worried about." I omitted the fact that my Mom probably would be
hearing the message I left right about now, hoping I wouldn't have to
deal with her until later in the evening.
It felt good to be able to spend time with Mike again, even under these
completely different circumstances. As we made some small talk and I
got to know this version of Mike, he still felt very much like the Mike
I knew. He had the same interests, including the old cheesy sports
movies that I had watched with him in my life, that he was still crazy
enough to find Captain America cooler than Iron Man, and that he still
liked to listen to Drake. I wanted to probe deeper, to try to tug at
the tail of the big elephant in the room, but I knew I should wait for a
bit longer before asking him about his family.
For his part, I tried my best to reveal Ally's life to him where I
could. But despite Ally's journals, I honestly didn't have an idea of
the small details of her life. But if she's supposed to be a version of
me, I have to believe that she'd be into Tony Stark as much as I was.
Frank personally delivered our order to us at the bar, taking the
opportunity to give Mike one final warning about being a proper
gentleman before leaving us to the rest of our evening. I really was
channeling my inner Britney because I don't think I'd get tired of
seeing Mike squirm nervously trying to appease a girl's paternal
figures. It was so terribly old fashioned of course, but that's
probably why I found it so funny to watch.
I couldn't help but nibble on some fries as Mike drove us back to his
place, giggling as he chastised me for hogging all of them. It was
probably the first time I felt truly comfortable since waking up as Ally
a few days ago. Riding in his car, joking with him about some stupid
video we had both seen, even if the moment was fleeting, I could forget
everything that had happened this week and just pretend it was any other
Friday night with my best friend.
Approaching his house, he turned to me and said, "Britney told me you
met my Dad the other day."
"I wouldn't say 'met'. Although Britney did seem eager to point me out
like I was a rare example of some kind of endangered species." I took
the opening as an opportunity to start probing him about his personal
life, "I was surprised your Dad was heading out so late though."
Mike shrugged his shoulders noncommittedly as he shut off the ignition.
We got out of the car and as we each retrieved our bags, he answered,
"That's the life of a detective."
Well, at least that was the same. "Is he too old for this shit?" I
jokingly ask him.
I heard a loud burst of laughter we approached his house before Mike
replied with, "Are you into old action movies too?"
I gave a non-committal "eh" to try to downplay what I knew was our
shared love of the cheesy movies from our fathers' youth. Mike opened
the door and held it open for me. I found myself nervous, unable to
cross the threshold. Perhaps part of it was Ally's reaction to being
alone with Mike in his home, but I know for my part it was being so
close to the seeing a tangible difference in this world... well, an
external one at least.
I could tell my nervousness was making Mike feel awkward and nervous in
kind, so I took a deep breath and stepped inside. The d?cor was
completely different from the last time I was here a week ago. I would
describe Mr. Taylor as a simple, spartan man and Mrs. Taylor - Mike's
biological mother - wasn't all that different. I wouldn't say that
their home was sterile or unwelcoming, but it was more functional in its
simplicity. Britney's mom must have had a big influence, because even
the entranceway was full of colour and objects d'art. Even the rug that
read "HOME" added a touch of personality that I knew wouldn't have come
from Mike or Mr. Taylor.
Continuing into the house, I was stopped by the sight of a large family
portrait that hung by the stairs up to the bedrooms. Britney's mom -
the new Mrs. Taylor? - served as such a stark contrast to Mike's mom.
The fact that there was even a family portrait in the hall was different
enough, but even the smile she gave when the photo was taken just exuded
warmth. Like she'd serve you a fresh piece of pecan pie with a scoop of
ice cream on top if you were feeling down and needed a pick me up. Not
that Mike's mom wasn't loving in her own way, but she was definitely
more reserved... very much like my mom, if I was going to be honest.
Maybe that's why they seemed to get along so well.
Mike caught me staring at the portrait and added some commentary, "What
you don't see there is Britney stamping on my foot, trying to get me to
ruin the picture."
His interruption was enough to bring me out of my thoughts as I mused,
"Living with her must be... a special treat."
He laughed as he led me to their living room, which was similarly
decorated in a way that was homier than I had known. He gestured toward
the couch and said, "Let me grab some plates for the burgers."
I nodded at him and waited for him to turn around before scanning the
living room for any clues about Mike's life that I could find. Like the
hallway I just passed through, the living room was practically
unrecognizable to me, presumably due to the changes introduced by
Britney and her mom. There was one thing that caught my eye on an
unfamiliar bookshelf by the wall - an old photo album that I vaguely
remembered flipping through.
For some reason I felt drawn to it and picked it up off the shelf,
flipping through some photos that I immediately recognized as a much
younger Mike. I think the album was a gift from one of Mike's
grandparents when he was born, so his parents had dutifully filled it
with pictures they probably wouldn't have printed otherwise. I tensed
up when I saw Mike's mom holding a baby and as I flipped through the
book, I relived Mike aging through childhood.
There was a picture of him being dropped off at summer camp and I froze.
This is where I would have met Mike and we became friends... but this
was also where Mike had pulled Ally out of the lake when she was
drowning. A memory that wasn't mine came to the surface, the feeling of
having water forcing its way into my throat as I struggled to reach the
surface to fill my lungs with precious oxygen. I felt panic begin to
overwhelm me as I failed to shake the memory from my mind.
I must have been so focused on memory of being in the lake that I didn't
notice Mike come up from behind me and let out a scream when I felt him
place his hand on my shoulder. I felt the album slip from my hands and
exclaimed "Oh shit!" as I pulled my arms together to catch it before it
fell any further.
"Are you okay?" Mike asked with concern on his face. He gently
caressed my shoulder and that's when I noticed that I was trembling,
perhaps from the anxiety of the memory, and took a few deep breaths that
followed the rhythm of his stroking to calm down. That's when I just
realized what was happening and turned red in embarrassment, sheepishly
looking away as I held the album up in front of me and offered it to
him.
"I just remembered camp and..."
A pang of sadness emanated from my chest as I felt the lingering
sensation of his touch against me. He carefully took the album from me
and placed it back on the shelf before putting his arm back on my
shoulder and gently guiding me to the couch, "It's okay Ally. I know I
don't know you that well, but I'm sure that was a very traumatic
experience." We sat down and he handed me a glass of water, encouraging
me to take a sip. "If there's anything I can do...," he offered me.
I sipped and nursed the glass for a second before shaking my head,
"Thanks, I'm better now."
He turned to look at the shelf again and mused, "You know, I didn't even
remember we had that. I guess Mom didn't..." he left the thought
unfinished and turned back to me with a small smile on his face.
I quickly found a lie to cover why I picked up the album in the first
place, "The design on the spine looked so interesting so I thought I'd
take a look..."
He shrugged and decided to change the subject by focusing back on me,
"Are you sure you're okay?"
"Yeah, I'm fine now. I guess... I guess that memory is still in my
mind. But I'm fine." I realized I had an opening though, and I took
the opportunity to raise my own concerns now before the moment had
passed, "So is that your mom...? She's very beautiful..." I let my
voice trail because I wasn't sure how he would take it, but I probably
wasn't going to get another opportunity to segue into his homelife
again.
He turned away from me and to the plates he had set up on the coffee
table in front of us so that I couldn't quite see his reaction. Pulling
out the burgers from the takeout bag, he quietly replied, "Yeah, that's
her. And yeah, she is."
I couldn't help but feel my mouth water at the sight, and more
importantly, the smell of the burgers as he laid them out on the plates
and dumped out some fries from the bag, but the food can wait. I
thought about how I would ask my question in a somewhat tactful manner.
"Do you miss her?" It was perhaps an insensitive question, but I needed
to know the answer.
A nervous laugh came out of his mouth as he slowly picked up a fry and
tossed it into his mouth. He turned to face me again and nodded slowly,
"Yeah, I miss her a lot. But I know she's happy now, and so is my
father."
I guess that means I'm not here as some kind of magical matchmaker who
is supposed to bring his back family together. If only I was the star
of a sappy Disney movie. I don't know if it was me or Ally, but I felt
compelled to lean in close to him and squeeze his arm with against me in
a hug. As I leaned my head against his shoulder, I found myself lost in
his deep blue eyes again, noticing the twinge of sadness and a
thoughtful maturity that I don't think my Mike would have had. His
vulnerability only made him that much more attractive.
I suddenly realized what I was doing and quickly released him, as it was
now my turn to use the food in front of me as an excuse to not face him
for a moment. That was too scary! Ally can have whatever she wants,
just not while I'm here. As I reached for the plate I added quickly,
"I'm sure having Britney and her mom around is nice though."
He laughed, "It's certainly different that's for sure. They've actually
met a few times, my mother and my step-mother I mean, and I can say that
they're friendly enough with each other. But I know my mother is happy
with her career, and well, my step-mother and my father are happy. My
mother lives in L.A. now, and my step-mother keeps telling me how much
I'd love it there if I ever visited. But with football and all, I just
never had the time to take off, you know?"
I pulled the burger to my mouth and took a big bite, closing my eyes to
savour the taste of the meat. I'm glad that Joe's is a great burger no
matter where I happened to be. As I chewed, I nodded at Mike and
remembered all the practices we'd do in the summer to prepare for the
season. In between bites of my food, I mumbled, "Well when you win this
year you can bring the State trophy with you when you visit her."
He laughed again, although I'm not sure if it was at my sentiment or at
the fact that I didn't seem to have any pretense of manners or
propriety. I wasn't going to worry about being lady-like though,
whatever that might mean here. I was with my best friend, hanging out
at his place, having the best burgers in the world.
Before he could dig into his own burger though, I stopped him and said,
"Oh, put up the game!"
He flinched, "I was kind of hoping you'd forget that."
"Not on your life. We're going to make you champion and you'll carry
that damn trophy with you all the way to L.A."
He got up and fumbled with his backpack, digging through it for a few
seconds before retrieving a USB key. He connected his computer to the
big TV and plugged the key into the computer and solemnly said, "I know
you must have seen enough of the game to know that's easier said than
done." He started the recording and sat back in the chair as the game
started to play in front of us.
"Who made this recording anyway?"
"Coach's wife, I think."
"We'll have to find some way to thank her, because this is even better
than I expected."
She must have sat right at midfield on the bleachers and had a wide view
of the entire field, but she also had the knowledge to follow the ball
around and zoom in on the action whenever necessary. It was almost like
watching a professional production.
I nudged Mike with an elbow to encourage him to try his burger before
leaning forward to watch the screen. This was the same Brightman team
that I faced last year. Shane Dearborn was still their QB, and they had
the same offensive and defensive lineup.
As the game unfolded, I could see them run the familiar plays and make
the moves I expected. As Shane was shouting his plays out to his team,
I turned to Mike and told him exactly what I knew would happen and I was
right every time, much to Mike's chagrin. "I'll bet you a fry he's
going to try to run the ball himself," I'd suggest and pick at his plate
shortly after I was proven right.
When it came to the defence, I could see when they going to run blitz.
Although given how effective it was at shutting down Mike, they didn't
really have a reason to try any other defensive plays. During one
exchange, without turning to face Mike I asked, "Why didn't you throw
there?"
He didn't answer as we watch the blitz rush him as he got sacked. It
was at that moment that I realized that I had been doing most of the
talking once the game started. I didn't think twice about giving him my
unfiltered criticism because that's what our relationship was... or at
least in my real life. Now here was some cheerleader openly criticizing
him, perhaps a little too pointedly, and I had no idea how he had taken
any of it.
He reached over to stop the video and leaned back on the couch. I
tentatively turned to face him, afraid of what I would find. I didn't
want him to be mad, but a part of me would be disappointed if he had
such a fragile ego he couldn't take feedback from a girl. I was shaken
when I saw a sad look on his face. I had caught a glimpse of his
vulnerability the first day I spoke to him as Ally, but this seemed much
more profound, as if I had really struck a chord.
Without thinking, I sidled up to him and grabbed his arm again. But as
I began to apologize to him, he interrupted me, "No, Ally, you don't
have to... you're right." I flinched as I felt him punch the couch
cushion with his free arm. "And I appreciate you trying to help me.
Here, and at practice. But maybe... maybe I'm not..." He bit his lip,
unable to finish the thought.
Dammit. Did I push him too hard? I've never seen him in this state,
but I realized that I never had a reason to see him vulnerable. I
didn't have to be there when his parents got divorced, or when his dad
remarried, or when we lost a game, or... or even things that may have
happened to him that he kept from me simply because he didn't want to
tell anther guy.
I couldn't assume that this Mike would act like the one I've known my
entire life, even if he's so familiar to me. I couldn't be the friend
he clearly needed, and I don't even know if he had someone to talk to
about what he was feeling, but there was something I could give him. I
leaned in against his arm and squeezed it, feeling the warmth from his
big biceps flow into me. As I looked up at him, I could feel the
thumping of my heart as my nervous energy built up inside me.
Was I really going to do this?
I felt myself reach up in my seat as I brought my face closer to his,
watching as he reciprocated in turn and started lowering his head to
meet mine. We stopped when we were inches away from each other, both of
us feeling extremely tentative. For his part, perhaps it was his first
kiss. I knew it would be mine... but certainly not the one I expected.
Oh screw it.
I closed my eyes and pressed forward, closing the small yet seemingly
infinite distance between us, and felt my lips brush up against his. I
couldn't think anymore as a rush of emotion overwhelmed me. Was it joy?
Euphoria? I didn't know. All that mattered was this singular moment
where the only thought that was in my head was the pure bliss of this
moment. Whoever I was, wherever I was, in that instant I didn't care
anymore.
I don't know how long we were kissing each other. Seconds? Minutes?
Time simply stood still. But the moment was rudely interrupted by both
our phones chirping, invading the bubble we had found ourselves in to
shake us back to reality.
I opened my eyes and in a state of shock, almost shoved him away as I
backed away from him. That was... damn. I don't know what that was.
Too embarrassed to face him at the moment, I fumbled for my phone and
saw that Britney had messaged us, as promised, to warn us that they were
headed home. I let out a nervous giggle as I realized Britney had
broken up the moment she teased me about all week, and much to my relief
I heard Mike join me with his own nervous laugh as he began to process
what had just happened.
I took a deep breath and turned to face him again, feeling the need to
fill the silence before he said anything. "I..." Now was such a great
time to be at a loss for words, wasn't it? I turned to face the screen
and saw Mike lying on the field after yet another sack. Football!
Choosing to ignore what just happened, I tried to continue our
conversation as if nothing happened, "I know if we work on your vision,
we can get you to get the ball out of your hands faster."
My heart was still beating and I was clearly flushed with excitement,
but I did my best to tamper down Ally's physical reaction with a mental
cold shower. I was just helping him get over himself the only way that
I could in the moment. There was absolutely, God as my witness, no
other motivation behind that kiss!
I continued to ignore Mike, hoping he would get the message, and
continued to watch the game unfold in front of me. "See, you do better
when you know you know it's a running play. You even get a block in!"
I felt him lean forward as well, but I was still afraid to face him. As
the seconds passed from the kiss, it already felt like a mistake to me.
It just seemed like such an obvious solution, to give him an 'easy win',
but it also felt like I was playing on his insecurities and manipulating
him to help him regain some of his confidence.
Well, there's also the whole I JUST KISSED MY BEST FRIEND thing finally
started to dawn on me. As that thought permeated my mind, I could feel
the blood rush to my face as I started to blush again. Although this
time the embarrassment was definitely all mine. I stuttered as I tried
to refocus my attention back on the game and talk about some of the
things he might work on, but he didn't seem to take the hint. Or he
simply didn't care.
My eyes widened as I felt him take my hand, his grip tightening as our
fingers interlocked. I had the foresight to bite my lip to trap the
yelp of surprise that I could feel forming in my throat. I turned my
head slightly and saw that he was playing it completely cool, and if I
didn't know him better, I almost would have believed he played me like a
fiddle and got exactly what he wanted. At least I didn't think he'd be
the type to try to manipulate someone into feeling sorry for him.
Feeling the warmth of his hand against mine, I would be lying if I said
I hated it. Just like when I was in the car with him, the familiarity
was comforting. Not that I was ever this intimate with my Mike, or at
least in this particular way...
A stray thought occurred to me. If someone set up this whole experience
just so I could learn something about my feelings for Mike, then they
really went to a whole lot of trouble.
I closed my eyes and waited for something to happen.
A nefarious voice pierced through the air in the room, "HEY LOVEBIRDS!"
This time I did yank my hand away from Mike and practically fell off the
couch as I tried to scramble to my feet. Seconds later I saw Britney's
playful grin as she ran into the living room. I wouldn't be surprised
if Britney was a magical creature and I was her plaything at this point.
It'd be as rational as any other explanation I've come up with so far,
and given how much she seemed to enjoy toying with me it didn't seem all
that implausible.
After the initial shock of her entrance, I couldn't help but burst into
a fit of laughter. Is this my life now? Living as a girl being
tortured by Britney for the rest of my days?
Britney was certainly not pleased with my unexpected reaction, although
I could see her smirk when she saw that Mike was as flustered as she
expected me to be.
When I recovered from my laughter, I responded to her dryly, "Hey
Britney, how was your night out with your parents?"
Not missing a beat, she beamed and said, "It was great! We went out for
Chinese!" She ambled over to me and thrust what I recognized was a
fortune cookie into my hand before whispering, "A little treat for you
after the main course?"
I wanted to show her that I wasn't flustered, so with a purposeful
deliberateness I opened the wrapper and pulled out the cookie, snapping
it in half and popping it in my mouth as I read the little piece of
paper that was inside.
'True love is where you least expect it.'
Thankfully I had already swallowed the bite of the cookie because I'm
sure I would have choked right then and there. Britney was looking at
me expectantly, and I gave a look at Mike before I burst into another
fit of laughter.
Mike quickly scrambled over to me to try to save me from Britney. Or
perhaps he was wondering if he was the butt of some kind of inside joke
between us. I handed the piece of paper to Britney and watched as she
excitedly jumped up and down before she handed it to Mike who
immediately blushed and shyly turned to face me. At this point if this
was some kind of elaborate joke being played on me, I might as well roll
with it.
When Mike and Britney's parents walked in, I tensed up and stood at
attention. The first thing I noticed immediately was that Mr. Taylor -
or Brian as Britney called him - was fairly different from the one I
knew. Mike's dad wasn't stern per se, but he was definitely more of the
quiet and serious type. Not this version of Mr. Taylor though, he was
practically jovial. I turned to face the new Mrs. Taylor and I could
see where Britney got her energy from. She exuded vivaciousness and a
love of life that could disarm anyone, including Mike's dad, and her
smile was more than enough to get me to relax as the both of them
approached us.
Mrs. Taylor smiled at me and said, "You must be Ally!"
"Yes ma'am," I tentatively replied before glancing at Britney and
jokingly adding, "I'm not sure what Britney has been saying about me,
but I assure you it's all exaggerated!"
She laughed before giving me a quick hug, "Please, call me Rose. And
it's all been good things! Quite frankly I thought she might have been
making you up." I could see the same playful glint in her eye that I
recognized in Britney. She released me and added, "she was so scared of
trying out for the squad last year, but she said you encouraged her to
try out. You're practically her hero!"
Britney shouted in protest, "Mom!"
This was just too cute. That's when Mr. Taylor interrupted us to
introduce himself, "I'm Michael's father, but I'm sure you've deduced
that already." He turned to Mike and nodded at the game still playing
on the TV behind us and said, "I'll admit I was skeptical when both
Michael and Britney conspired to have us out of the home so that the two
of you could watch a football game in private."
Now it was Mike's turn to feel embarrassed, "Dad!"
Watching Mike being teased by his father was something else and I
couldn't help but let out another laugh. I know my Mike had a much
different relationship with his parents, but I couldn't say that this
reality was any worse. And if Mike's mother was happier as well being
able to pursue her career in California, who was I to think I was sent
here to 'fix' things?
I couldn't help but be caught up in Mr. and Mrs. Taylor's energy and
gave Mike's father a playful wink, "I assure you sir, your son has been
the perfect gentleman." The mood changed when we all saw that the game
was practically over as our team was blown out. I tried to diffuse the
situation by reassuring them, "Mike's going to be great this year.
He'll widen up his vision and take us to State. I promise!"
Mr. Taylor laughed, but before he could respond my phone started to
ring. I reached into my pocket and apologetically pulled it out, before
realizing that it was Mom. "Oh sh-", I stopped as the word was forming
in my mouth before finishing with, "-ugar." Real smooth. "Sorry, it's
my Mom."
It was Britney's turn to tease me, "Oh I thought you and 'Stella' had a
mature and understanding relationship!"
I made a face at her and was about to say something until Mrs. Taylor
swooped in and plucked the phone out of my hand. I watched in shock as
she answered the phone and placed it up to her ear, "Hi, Stella? I'm
Rose, Britney and Michael's mother. That's right! Oh, you don't have
to worry, we've been here the whole time. Your daughter is quite the
angel, but I'm sure you know that. Uh huh. Now you don't need to do
that! It's quite late and it wouldn't make sense for you to come all
the way out here just to fetch her. Sure! She'll spend the night with
Britney, they wanted to have a sleepover anyway and I don't mind. I'll
personally deliver her back to you tomorrow morning. Oh, it's no
trouble at all! Like I said, your daughter is perfect! Alright then,
I'll let you talk to Ally now."
What the hell just happened?! Did she just out talk Mom?
Mrs. Taylor supressed a laugh as she handed the phone back to me. It
took me a few seconds to pick my jaw off the floor before I took the
phone from her and started to talk to Mom, "Hey..."
"Yeah..." I heard her say.
Move over Britney, there's a new force of nature in town. Seeing the
expectant eyes of the Taylor family on me, I eventually recovered and
said, "So I guess I'll be home tomorrow..."
"Right..."
I can't believe she's going along with this. Maybe she's still
experiencing the same shell shock that I'm feeling right now. "Well...
goodnight?"
"Goodnight..."
I stared at my phone as it disconnected and my brain finally caught with
what just happened. Wait.... Did I just agree to be trapped here for
the evening? I looked up at Britney and her mom and could see them
beaming at me. I think I finally understand what people mean when they
say someone is a force of nature.
As I turned to face the Taylor, I wasn't sure if I was more caught off
by the fact that Mike's eyes were practically bulging out of his head or
by Mr. Taylor laughing at what his wife had just orchestrated. Britney
gave me a hug and shouted, "Slumber party!!!"
I tried to work up a response, "I don't want to be a bother... I don't
have a change of clothes..."
Mrs. Taylor smiled and said, "Now, sending you and Mike out there alone
at night unsupervised wouldn't be so wise of me would it? And you are
quite tall, but I'm sure we'll find something for you to wear tonight.
Besides, I'm sure Michael wouldn't mind lending you something out of his
closet if push came to shove."
I was at a loss for words and couldn't think of a response, but
thankfully Mike took charge and pulled me away from his family and back
toward the couch, "Now that everyone's had their fun, we need to get
back to work. Ally's here to help me after all."
Britney excitedly said, "I'll get my room ready! Unless she's spending
the night in your room Mike!"
Mrs. Taylor laughed in response, but mercifully she reigned her daughter
in and gestured toward the stairs back in the hall, "Come on, I'll help
you out. I'm sure we have our camping stuff somewhere."
I turned to Mike and we both breathed a sigh of relief when they were
gone. I couldn't help myself and spurted out, "I'm exhausted."
It was Mr. Taylor's turn to laugh, "They really do sweep you up in their
pace, don't they?" He turned serious for a moment and gently asked,
"I'm happy to give you a lift home if you'd like though."
I turned to face Mike for a second and when I caught his eye, he turned
away from me and pretended to fidget with the computer to get back to
where we had left off before his family had returned. I don't know if
I'd be mortified at the prospect of a girl I liked staying over at my
house during our first 'date' or if I'd be excited at the rather
unprecedented opportunity of having her spend the night, but I think
from the way he was trying to NOT look at me, he made it clear that he
hoped I would stay.
I shook my head, "No, I'm fine. I just didn't expect to be spending the
night... and certainly not my mom either."
I sat back down on the couch and Mike joined me, and before it could get
any more awkward between the two of us, I asked his father to join us as
well. As we watched the last of the game unfold, I made some small talk
to try to learn more about this version of Mr. Taylor. It was odd
telling him about my parents, since in my mind they had been friends for
most of my childhood, but it gave me an opportunity to learn more about
him and his relationship with Britney's mom. He even seemed to be on
friendly terms with Mike's mom, which made me feel a little bit of
relief.
Maybe I'm not here to try to 'fix' something... maybe I'm here to learn
that people can be happy regardless of their circumstances.
I looked down at my body and held in a sigh as the Taylors started
talking about what Mike could work on. If this is the lesson that the
universe, God, or whatever, wants me to learn I'm not sure I'm ready to
accept it. I'm sure being a girl perfectly fine, but I'd more than
ready to go back to my life as a guy now.
That said, it did give me one piece of advice I could give Mike though,
"You might still have some doubts in your mind, but what's on the screen
now? That has already happened and you can't change that. What you CAN
change is how approach Friday's game. So, tonight is the last time we
feel bad about what happened and tomorrow we drill the playbook over and
over again and we keep working on the passing game." I paused for a
second before realizing what I said and quickly added, "I mean 'you'...
you need to do that."
Mr. Taylor agreed, "She's not wrong. Listen, tomorrow we'll go throw
the ball around a bit and work on your fundamentals."
"Sure Dad."
"I could help too," I chimed in without hesitation. I could see the
look of surprise on their faces, but Mr. Taylor smiled and nodded at me.
And, well, Mike was trying his best to hide a smile on his face and
doing a pretty bad job at it.
We chatted football for a few more minutes before Britney and her mother
came back downstairs and told us that everything was ready. Short of
Mom bursting through the door to drag me home, this was really
happening. But I suppose dealing with Britney's teasing wasn't the end
of the world, and her constant needling seemed to work well enough to
keep Mike at bay, even if it was embarrassing to the both of us.
Getting to know her better, Britney's mother was as warm and genuine as
her first impression made her out to be, and it wasn't long before I
felt like she was the 'cool Aunt' I had always known my entire life.
Given the tension I sensed from Mike and Britney when they each spoke
about their step-parents, it seemed a bit uncouth for me to ask, but I
thought I should try to close the loop on my investigation and asked
Mrs. Taylor, "How did you and Mr. Taylor meet?"
She smiled at me and shot Mr. Taylor a loving look before giving a
gentle laugh. "I'm sure these two are tired of the story," she said as
she looked at Mike and Britney, "but he ran into my car."
Mr. Taylor groaned and shook his head, "More like 'someone' stopped
without warning because she spilled some coffee on herself."
"I plead the Fifth!"
They both shared a laugh while Britney and Mike put expressions of
patience on their faces in order to humour their parents' reminiscences.
There really was nothing for me to 'fix' here, was there? And it didn't
seem like one version of reality was 'better' than the other, it was
just a different path that everyone here was on. I wasn't sure if I
should be disappointed that there wasn't some kind of straight forward
'mission' for me to complete so that I could get back to my own life, or
simply grateful that everyone seemed happy here. In a way, it was a bit
of a relief even if it didn't solve my immediate problem...
I will say, it'll probably take me awhile to get used to seeing Mr.
Taylor being so playful with Mrs. Taylor. I grimaced as the thought
entered my mind - I was starting to get too comfortable again. As much
as I enjoyed my time tonight, even that... moment with Mike wasn't TOO
bad... I know that this isn't where I belong. It's starting to get
harder to remember that though.
We continued to chat into the evening, and at several points I had to
try to remain vague about certain aspects of my life because I still
didn't quite have the details of everything Ally had done up until now.
Hey, it's hard enough trying to keep up with her current life let alone
trying to fill in the gaps from the last 18 years! I wondered if both
Mr. and Mrs. Taylor were sizing me up to see if I'd be a good fit with
Mike, because some of the questions were about my future and as much as
I got to know Ally this past week, I really didn't want to think about
what her life would be like come next Fall. A cheerleading scholarship
somewhere? Or maybe an academic one, since her grades were pretty
good... She seemed to be in a good place and had her whole future ahead
of her at least.
I couldn't tell if Mike was put off by the fact that I was fitting in
with his family so easily. I already had a rapport with Mr. Taylor, and
with his new friendly demeanor it was trivial to get on his good side by
appealing to our shared hatred of the Patriots. And of course, Mrs.
Taylor was pretty much the definition of affability, although her
complements about my makeup or feminine physique stung more than I
thought they would because they reminded me of what I had accidentally
become. But even if Mike was annoyed by the fact that I was happy to
spend time with his parents, I noticed that he took the opportunity to
sit a little TOO close to me. I hope the kiss didn't go to his head,
because that was definitely and most definitively a one-time thing!
As the evening drew to a close, I sense Mike tensing up as I'm sure he
wasn't prepared to have me stay over. If it weren't for the fact that
he had to deal with Britney everyday, I probably would have teased him a
little.
Britney chimed in, right on cue, and suggested, "What if we raid Mike's
closet for something you can wear?" She giggled as she jumped out of
her seat and started running upstairs, a wide-eyed and horrified Mike
chasing after her.
I smiled awkwardly at the Taylor parents and shrugged my shoulders, "I
should probably rescue Mike from Britney. Thank you for a wonderful
evening, Mr. and Mrs. Taylor."
Mrs. Taylor laughed and said sweetly, "You really are cool as a
cucumber, aren't you? But I really must insist that you call me Rose
from now on."
"I'll try my best..." I hesitated as I couldn't quite find the courage
to call her by her first name before settling on "ma'am." I wasn't
feeling quite as cucumber-ish as she thought I was, as I nervously waved
at the both of them before running after Mike and Britney. I heard Mrs.
Taylor tell Mr. Taylor that I was 'really cute' and would be 'great for
Mike' and couldn't help but blush as I climbed up the stairs, hoping to
avoid hearing any more of their conversation.
I heard some noise coming out of Mike's room, and out of habit I just
pushed the door open and barged in, hoping to resolve the little sibling
squabble.
"ALLY!", Mike exclaimed, before catching himself and frantically looking
around his bedroom hoping to clean up whatever mess he might want to
hide from a girl. His room wasn't all that different from what I
remembered in my own life, and if he had anything embarrassing it'd
probably be on his computer than anything he might have hid under his
bed or anything like that. Ignoring him for the moment, I went over to
Britney who was gleefully rummaging through his closet and firmly put a
hand on her shoulder before grabbing a sweater and a pair of sweatpants.
As I nudged Britney out of the room, I turned to Mike and said, "I'll
get these back to you tomorrow... Thanks!" Before stepping out of the
room, I poked my head back in and said, "I love that guitar, but you
might want to change the strings." I figured that would help take his
mind off... well, me. Even if it was just to confuse him.
Britney laughed as she led me to her room - what I remembered as the
'other' Mrs. Taylor's study - and pulled me inside before shutting the
door behind me and squealing, "Come on, you have to tell me what
happened while you two were alone!"
I wanted to brush her off, but I remembered that I had kissed Mike in
that one moment and immediately began to blush. I quickly turned away
from her, but it was too late. She let out a joyful squeal - one that
I'm sure the whole house heard - before pulling me toward her bed asking
me to tell her, in her words, EVERYTHING.
I wasn't ready to relive that moment, so I shook my head 'no' and told
her, "Let's talk about anything else." I collapsed back into her bed,
grabbing one of her pillows and pressing it against my face in an
attempt to hide from reality. This had to be Ally asserting herself,
but the fact that it felt so... so good to kiss him was undeniable. I
really didn't want to think about what that meant, particularly when I
got home. How much of what happened here would stick with me? I let
out a muffled scream into the pillow in frustration which only caused
Britney, who already assumed I was embarrassed, to laugh even more.
I felt her fall to the bed beside me and let her pull the pillow off my
face. She gave me a sympathetic look and said, "It's okay if you don't
want to talk about it. I'm just happy for you and Mike."
With a big sigh I replied, "There's nothing to be happy about okay?
We're just..." I didn't even know how to describe what I thought our
relationship would be. "We're something, but just not that." I turned
to face her so that I could quickly explain myself, "It's not Mike! I
just have some things to figure out."
She rolled over to turn her back to me and quietly said, "I think you
two would be happy together. I'm also being a bit selfish, but I was
serious this morning. If the two of you started dating, I'd have a
reason to stay in touch with you when you leave." Rather than
interrupt, I let the awkward silence linger in the air as I waited for
her to continue. She curled up a little and continued, "Mom was right.
I was feeling really down last year after my Dad... well, then you
encouraged me to join the cheerleading team. It was... I... you don't
know how much that meant to me."
I slowly reached for her shoulder and gently squeezed, trying to access
some of those memories of trying to help Britney last year. All I could
recall were some general emotions, of feeling sad because Britney was
feeling down and feeling happy when she took so well to being a part of
the team. I drew my hand back when I felt her move, rolling back around
to face me. I could see some tears forming in her eyes, that she
gruffly wiped away with her hand before cursing about ruining her
makeup.
I held her hands to stop her from pawing at her face and told her,
"There's no reason we can't still be friends even if I have nothing to
do with Mike."
She clicked her tongue and shook her head, "You'll be at college and
have a bunch of new friends who will take you out to cool college
parties and things like that. I'll just be the immature senior that you
won't think about anymore."
I laughed and pinched her cheek, "I promise you that I'll never forget
you."
She squealed and shoved my hand away before laughing herself. She gave
me a conspiratorial smile, "If your brother doesn't make a move on Mary,
I could always start dating him. Maybe YOU could be the one who
babysits our kids?"
Poor Steve! I'm sure he sensed a 'disturbance in the Force' at that
moment. In a mock pleading voice, I replied, "Please don't hurt my
brother!" I reached for her hand and gave it a squeeze, "But seriously,
I'd sad if we weren't still friends regardless of... well, the guys in
our lives."
"Oh, the Bechdel test!"
"Exactly!" I'd never thought I'd be the subject a particular form of
feminist media discourse, but here we are. I got up from the bed and
started to change into the clothes Britney pilfered from Mike. Whatever
form of self-consciousness I felt about my body was long since gone,
being desensitized by the time I spent in the locker room and in my
shower.
As Britney began to remove her makeup, she asked, "What about Jen? I
don't think she likes me much, particularly after this week..."
I still hadn't figured that out. I think she was perhaps a little
jealous that someone else was encroaching on our relationship. It
should probably be a matter of reassuring her that she'd always be my
closest friend or even like a sister to me. I just needed to be
sensitive about her insecurities, although without really knowing her
history with Ally, it might be easier said than done. As I borrowed
some of Britney's wipes to clean off my own face, I told Britney, "I
think she's feeling a little left out, but I'll talk to her. I think
it'd be great if we could all be friends."
I felt Britney give me a hug from behind braced myself for her
inevitable verbal jab, "You can tell her that she can be your maid of
honor when you marry Mike."
I groaned and reached behind me to poke at her sides, causing her to
release me. I turned around and started to tickle her sides, causing
her to squirm and squeal as she reached for a pillow on her bed and
smacked me with it. It didn't take long for me to find my own pillow
and hit her back, starting a very loud and protracted pillow fight that
escalated to the point where Mr. Taylor had to knock loudly on Britney's
door to get us to stop. A pillow fight was the last thing I'd ever
thought I'd do, but I was happily lost in the moment and forgot my
troubles.
As foreign as this life was to me, as strange as it was to live my life
as a girl... I had to admit that I enjoyed it. Just like the Taylors I
met tonight, it's not that my previous life was better or worse... it
was simply different. That didn't mean I was admitting defeat though,
but it's nice knowing that there wasn't anything horrible I necessarily
had to deal with if I was actually stuck here.
We finally settled down and began get ready for the night, as Britney
led me to the bathroom so that I could brush my teeth and get ready for
bed. Back in her room, I slipped into the sleeping bag that was laid
out beside her bed and we spent the next little while speaking to each
other in whispered tones about our lives and our hopes for the future.
I didn't have much to say of course, but I was glad that Britney was
thinking about taking on the role of Varsity captain next year, because
I'm sure she'd be great at it.
Before we went to sleep, she rolled over and looked down at me and said,
"I'm glad you stayed over. It's been a while since anyone... well...
it's just been a while."
There was still some aspect of Britney's history that I couldn't quite
grasp that Ally would have known. I resolved to read through Ally's
journals this weekend so that I wouldn't be caught unprepared again.
But I was able to return her sentiment at least and said, "I didn't
expect to stay here tonight, but I'm glad I did. Next time though, I
think we'll do this at my place."
"Deal! And I can find out some more about my potential future husband
Steve."
I suppressed a laugh and simply said, "Goodnight Bea."
I listened as she settled into her bed, "Sweet dreams!", she replied
quietly before silence settled into the room.
As I listened to the soft breathing of Britney beside me, I couldn't
help by laugh at the absurdity of it all. I imagined that my first
night with a girl would be memorable, but I never could have come up
with something as fantastical as the situation I found myself in now.
Well, at least I survived by 'date' with Mike mostly intact, even if I
now have more questions than answers. If I'm not here to fix his life,
then why am I here? My mind wandered back to the scientific explanation
that had first struck me on my first day as Ally. If Dr. Rowan won't
get back to me, maybe I need to find a way to get her to speak to me.
However, the thought was left unformed as my eyes began to close and I
drifted slowly into the peacefulness of sleep.
Quite a big day for Ally, wasn't it? I hope you're enjoying the story!
I was perhaps too optimistic about posting more frequently, but I hope
the fact that the chapters are a bit longer makes up for it. I think
future chapters will be about the same length, so I may end up keeping
this schedule going for the time being. Just know that I'm still
plugging away at the story one sentence at a time.
Also thank you for leaving reviews and sending notes, it's much
appreciated encourages me to keep on writing!
As always, feel free to leave a comment here or to reach out to me at
[email protected] if you'd like.
Thank you!